The Evolving Landscape of College Admissions: A Focus on Washington University in St. Louis
On August 28, 2024, Washington University in St. Louis (WashU) released its admissions statistics for the Class of 2028, revealing notable progress in enrolling low-income and first-generation college students following the U.S. Supreme Court’s ban on race-conscious admissions. Among the 1,851 new students, 18% are first-generation college students, hailing from 49 states and 32 countries. However, the university faces challenges, particularly a 4% decline in the proportion of Black/African American freshmen, despite stable percentages of Asian, White, and Hispanic students. The percentage of students who did not disclose their race has increased by 4%, resulting in a total of 47% of the incoming class identifying as students of color, down from 53% the previous year.
Ronné Turner, the Associate Vice Chancellor for Enrollment and Financial Aid, expressed excitement about the diversity and talent of the incoming class. Out of 32,753 applicants, approximately 12% were admitted. The proportion of students receiving financial aid rose from 42% to 48%, with the average financial aid package nearing $72,000, an increase of nearly $6,000. Turner emphasized that the university’s new financial aid initiatives, such as the no-loan program, have enabled more students in need of financial assistance to enroll.
In discussing the impact of the Supreme Court ruling on the admissions process, Turner noted that racial information has been removed from applications, and the admissions committee does not consider race data in their evaluations and selections. Nevertheless, the university encourages students to share how their racial identity has influenced their experiences and opportunities in their applications. Turner also highlighted that admissions decisions are not based on a single factor; the university employs a holistic review process that considers students’ academic achievements, experiences, and potential.
To address the challenges in admissions, WashU plans to expand its admissions team, particularly in regions like Atlanta and Texas, to better reach and recruit talented students from rural and small-town backgrounds. Additionally, the university has partnered with QuestBridge to directly admit high-achieving low-income students who did not match with their preferred schools.
Despite the challenges posed by the Supreme Court’s ruling, WashU’s commitment to diversity and financial aid reflects its dedication to educational equity. This commentary will delve deeper into the implications of the Supreme Court ruling on college admissions policies across the United States, trends in diversity among college freshmen, the role of economic aid in increasing access for low-income students, strategies for recruiting students from rural areas, and the effectiveness of test-optional policies in college admissions processes.

Impact of Supreme Court Ruling on College Admissions Policies in the U.S.
The Supreme Court’s decision on July 2, 2024, to eliminate race-based admissions policies has significantly altered the landscape of college admissions in the United States. Bryan Cook, Director of Higher Education Policy at the Urban Institute, has been tracking the ruling’s impact on diversity in higher education. However, he notes that this process is more complex than anticipated. Many institutions have begun to adjust their application materials and financial aid policies to comply with the new legal environment. Some schools have even increased the space in applications for students to reflect their identities to mitigate legal risks.
Despite the nationwide discussions on diversity and equity sparked by the ruling, assessing its specific impact on selective colleges remains challenging. Cook points out that preliminary data shows no significant changes in the racial composition of applicants, but the lack of publicly available admissions data complicates the analysis of these changes. The federal Department of Education’s Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) only provides data by gender, not by race, making it difficult for researchers to understand the relationship between admissions policies and applicant diversity.
Cook emphasizes that collecting and analyzing data from 2024 and 2025 will be crucial for understanding future equitable admissions policies. While some schools have taken steps to ensure diversity post-ruling, many have reduced transparency in their admissions policies due to legal risks, making it difficult for the public to fully grasp the changes.
Moreover, Cook notes that issues with the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) have shifted attention away from the ruling’s impact, particularly concerning low-income students. The complexity of FAFSA may pose challenges for many low-income families, potentially leading to a decline in applications and admissions for underrepresented minority students.
Different states have reacted to the ruling in various ways, with some expanding the interpretation of financial aid to include racial factors, thereby limiting the measures schools can take in admissions. Nevertheless, Cook believes that current research faces challenges, particularly in the absence of sufficient data to evaluate the long-term effects of the ruling on diversity.
In summary, while the Supreme Court’s ruling may not have immediately altered the racial composition of applicants, the future of admissions policies and diversity in higher education requires close monitoring. As data continues to be collected and analyzed, the educational community will gain a clearer understanding of the ruling’s profound implications.
Trends in Diversity Among College Freshmen in the United States Post-2024
Despite a general decline in college enrollment numbers across the nation, Franklin College in Indiana welcomed its largest freshman class in recent years, comprising 354 new students on August 27, 2024. This cohort not only boasts a significant number of students but also excels academically, with over 80% of freshmen ranking in the top half of their high school GPA. Andrew Hendricks, Vice President of Enrollment and Marketing at Franklin College, noted that this year’s acceptance rate is the lowest in over a decade, enhancing the academic quality of the institution.
During the welcome event, the campus buzzed with energy as students engaged in various activities, showcasing their enthusiasm. Hendricks pointed out that despite facing the so-called “enrollment cliff”—a decline in the number of high school graduates—Franklin College’s high enrollment rate has positively impacted the campus environment. Data indicates that college enrollment rates in Indiana have reached historic lows, with only 53% of the 2022 graduating class choosing to pursue higher education, leading many Indiana students to seek college opportunities out of state.
This year’s freshman class includes 36 international students from 13 countries, including Barbados, Brazil, Canada, Ecuador, Mexico, Nepal, Puerto Rico, Serbia, Spain, Venezuela, and Zimbabwe. Notably, the largest group of international students hails from Nepal, with 22 students. Hendricks emphasized that Nepal has become a significant source of students for U.S. and Canadian institutions, and Franklin College’s success in international recruitment is a result of building strong relationships with students, families, and recruitment agencies in various countries.
The diversity of the student body brings new perspectives and opportunities for cultural exchange to the campus. The college’s priority strategy in international recruitment will further enhance campus diversity. As domestic students increasingly express interest in studying abroad, students from different regions will contribute to the overall strategic implementation of the institution.
Franklin College’s success reflects the institution’s efforts and achievements in recruitment. Hendricks stated that they have already begun preparations for the Class of 2025, hoping to maintain this positive momentum.
Role of Economic Aid in Increasing College Access for Low-Income Students
In a recent article published on October 31, 2023, Jan Jaro highlighted the critical role community colleges play in promoting economic mobility, employment, and local vitality. Compared to four-year institutions, community colleges are more inclusive, aiming to provide learning and employment opportunities for individuals from diverse backgrounds. However, community colleges face funding challenges, as they must serve a wide range of students, from high-achieving high school graduates to adults seeking skill certifications. This resource dispersion makes it difficult to meet the non-academic needs of low-income students, such as childcare and transportation. Many community college degrees fail to yield economic returns, with numerous students unable to recoup their investments within five years of graduation.
To address these issues, policymakers should implement reforms in two key areas: first, adjust curricula to align with high-paying and in-demand fields, increasing work-based learning opportunities; second, the federal government should provide more financial aid, such as increasing Pell Grants and transportation subsidies, to help more students successfully complete their studies.
The student population at community colleges is diverse, with over 30% of students being non-traditional, 45% being minorities, and 63% attending part-time, which negatively impacts retention and graduation rates. Low-income students face even greater challenges, as community colleges primarily rely on local and state government funding, resulting in less funding for schools with higher proportions of low-income students. The U.S. urgently needs more nurses, IT professionals, and skilled workers, but recruitment and training channels are often understaffed and highly fragmented.
Moreover, the value of community college degrees and certificates varies significantly, with certain technical degrees and certifications offering much higher returns on investment (ROI) than others. Research indicates that degrees in nursing, engineering, and computer science can effectively recoup investments within five years, while degrees in the humanities often yield little economic return. To address these disparities, policymakers, community college leaders, employers, and philanthropic organizations should collaborate to implement five key reforms:
1. Realign community college curricula to focus on high-ROI technical degrees and certifications.
2. Foster partnerships between community colleges and local employers to provide scalable workforce training.
3. Increase the amount of Pell Grants to improve degree affordability.
4. Develop and fund high-ROI support services, such as career counseling and textbook subsidies.
5. Create comprehensive data tracking mechanisms to assess student learning outcomes.
Through these reforms, community colleges can more effectively serve students and local communities, becoming a source of economic opportunity, particularly for those from disadvantaged backgrounds. While these reforms require time and effort, their potential positive outcomes warrant investment.
Strategies for Recruiting Students from Rural and Small-Town Areas in Higher Education
On July 24, 2024, Vanderbilt University announced the expansion of the STARS (Students Taking Action for Rural Students) network, which aims to create more higher education opportunities for students from small towns and rural areas. Initially launched in April 2023 by Vanderbilt University and 15 other prestigious institutions, the network will welcome 16 new members, including Amherst College, Auburn University, Dartmouth College, Duke University, Georgia Institute of Technology (2024 USNews Ranking: 33) , Southern Methodist University, Spelman College, Stanford University, University of Alabama, University of Arizona, University of Arkansas, University of California-Berkeley, University of Denver, University of Notre Dame, University of South Carolina, and University of Texas at Austin.
The founding members of the STARS network include Brown University, California Institute of Technology, Case Western Reserve University, Colby College, Columbia University, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Northwestern University, Ohio State University, University of Chicago, University of Iowa, University of Maryland, University of Southern California, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Vanderbilt University, Washington University in St. Louis, and Yale University. The network is co-led by the University of Chicago and Vanderbilt University, based in Chicago.
The STARS network’s goal is to ensure that students from small towns and rural areas receive the necessary information and support to successfully enroll and graduate. Each member institution combines its resources with STARS’ philanthropic support to provide pipeline programs and recruitment efforts, as well as financial aid and campus support. Douglas L. Christensen, Vice Chancellor at Vanderbilt University, stated that STARS’ efforts have already yielded significant results, and the addition of 16 new members will further expand its impact, encouraging more students to pursue higher education.
Over the next decade, STARS is expected to receive $7.4 billion in funding, including financial aid directly provided by participating institutions and new funding from foundations, non-profit organizations, and government agencies. The Trotter Family Foundation will increase its initial $20 million donation by over $150 million to support programs that prepare, recruit, and support rural students.
In its first year, STARS outreach efforts reached 1.6 million individuals, including students, families, educators, administrators, foundations, legislators, corporations, and other organizations, directly interacting with over 700,000 students. STARS’ inaugural activities included visits to 1,100 rural high schools across 49 states, providing information about diverse higher education institutions, organizing campus tours for students and educators, hosting monthly virtual panel discussions to address math preparedness gaps, and collaborating with local and national businesses to offer internships and job opportunities.
The expansion of the STARS network aims to inspire other institutions, alumni, and philanthropists to increase their support for rural students. Research indicates that college graduates from rural areas often return to their communities, creating a positive cycle of support, success, and giving back to the next generation.
Vanderbilt University has played a significant role in outreach efforts in small towns and rural communities, particularly in Tennessee, which has the fifth-largest rural population in the U.S. Since the establishment of STARS, Vanderbilt has participated in various activities, including co-presenting at the 2024 Southern Association for College Admission Counseling annual conference, organizing the STARS Southern Tour, and hosting regional celebration events.
These efforts have yielded remarkable results, with the number of applicants from small towns and rural areas in Tennessee increasing by 26.8% and the number of admissions rising by 93.9% for the fall of 2024.
Effectiveness of Test-Optional Policies in College Admissions Processes
The debate surrounding standardized testing has resurfaced, particularly as many colleges reassess their test-optional policies implemented during the COVID-19 pandemic. Since the pandemic, numerous institutions have temporarily abandoned testing requirements due to the closure of testing centers, leading to widespread discussions about standardized exams. According to The New York Times, many colleges are contemplating whether to reinstate testing requirements, especially as admissions policies have evolved post-pandemic.
Over the past decade, the number of test-takers for standardized exams like the SAT and ACT has significantly declined, prompting many colleges to adopt test-optional policies. Data from the Department of Education indicates that from 2014 to 2019, the number of four-year institutions implementing test-optional policies increased by 13%. Some prestigious institutions, such as the University of California system and California Institute of Technology, have considered eliminating testing requirements altogether.
During the pandemic, all Ivy League schools were compelled to adopt test-optional policies, and many of these policies have continued beyond 2022. According to Common App data, only 4% of institutions required standardized test scores in the most recent application cycle.
Currently, many colleges that still maintain test-optional policies are evaluating whether to continue this approach. Columbia University and the College of William & Mary have decided to permanently uphold test-optional policies, while the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Georgetown University reinstated testing requirements in 2022.
The New York Times article highlights research from Harvard University indicating that standardized test scores are better predictors of academic ability than high school GPA. Co-founder of the study, John Friedman, noted that post-pandemic, schools have gained more data on the practical operation of test-optional policies, revealing significant uncertainty regarding students’ academic levels without test scores.
However, supporters of standardized testing face increasing challenges. Akil Bello, Senior Director of Fair Testing, argues that the role of standardized tests in admissions has diminished, and the future will hinge on whether these tests become completely marginalized in more selective institutions.
Christina Paxson, President of Brown University, mentioned in an article that while data suggests test scores are the best indicators of academic success at selective institutions, requiring tests may deter low-income and non-White students from applying. She has established a special committee to review Brown University’s admissions policies, including testing requirements.
Yale University and Cornell University are also reconsidering their test-optional policies. Friedman advises applicants to proceed cautiously and attempt to take standardized tests, as students without scores may face greater difficulties when applying to highly selective institutions.
Despite these challenges, 92% of officials at institutions that implemented test-optional policies during the pandemic expressed support for continuing this approach. With the Supreme Court ruling eliminating affirmative action, arguments against standardized testing have gained even more significance.
Testing companies faced significant challenges during the pandemic, with many companies laying off staff due to a decrease in test-takers. The year 2024 will be pivotal for the testing industry, as the College Board plans to launch a shortened digital SAT in the spring to test its success.
In conclusion, the debate over standardized testing remains a complex and sensitive topic in American higher education, encompassing issues of equity, academic ability, and admissions policies.
Conclusion
The admissions landscape at Washington University in St. Louis serves as a microcosm of the broader challenges and opportunities facing U.S. colleges today. The Supreme Court’s ruling on race-conscious admissions has prompted institutions to reevaluate their policies, leading to a complex interplay of diversity, equity, and access. As demonstrated by WashU’s efforts to enroll low-income and first-generation students, the commitment to educational equity remains strong, even in the face of challenges.
The trends in diversity among college freshmen, as seen in institutions like Franklin College, highlight the importance of proactive recruitment strategies and the role of international students in enriching campus life. Economic aid continues to be a critical factor in increasing access for low-income students, particularly in community colleges, which must adapt to meet the diverse needs of their student populations.
Furthermore, initiatives like the STARS network illustrate the importance of targeted outreach to rural and small-town students, ensuring that higher education opportunities are accessible to all. Finally, the ongoing debate over test-optional policies underscores the need for colleges to balance academic assessment with equitable access.
As U.S. colleges navigate these evolving dynamics, the commitment to fostering diversity, equity, and inclusion will be paramount in shaping the future of higher education. The experiences and strategies of institutions like Washington University in St. Louis will undoubtedly inform the broader discourse on admissions policies and practices in the years to come.
News References:
- WashU Enrollment Trends and Challenges
- Impact of Affirmative Action Ban on Higher Education
- Franklin College Welcomes Large Freshman Class Amid National Enrollment Decline
- Turning Community Colleges into Engines of Economic Mobility
- STARS College Network Expands Opportunities for Rural Students
- Reigniting the Standardized Testing Debate