Skip to content
College News

University of Florida Ranks No. 1 in City Journal’s New College Rankings

Published Updated 4 min read

(This article reports on news from October 2025.)

In October 2025, City Journal, a magazine published by the Manhattan Institute, launched a new set of college rankings that evaluate 100 prominent American colleges and universities. The University of Florida (UF) came first, with a four-star rating that, according to UF, only one other university received. A Wall Street Journal editorial, “The University Elite, Reconsidered,” highlighted the results (UF News, October 23, 2025; Manhattan Institute press release, October 22, 2025).

Futuristic university students engaging in project-based learning

What the City Journal rankings measure

Unlike rankings built largely on reputation, research output or wealth, the City Journal College Rankings score schools on 68 factors grouped into four categories: Leadership Quality, Educational Quality, Student Experience and Outcomes. They combine existing government data and other rating systems with newly developed indicators (Manhattan Institute). According to UF and press coverage, the factors include:

  • the strength of the general-education curriculum and academic rigor;
  • how well a school prepares graduates for careers, including how quickly they can repay the cost of their degree;
  • civil discourse, viewpoint diversity and ideological pluralism among faculty;
  • student tolerance for controversial speakers and campus free-speech climate.

Data sources cited in coverage include the American Council of Trustees and Alumni’s “What Will They Learn?” curriculum ratings, the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) free-speech ratings, and faculty campaign-donation records (OCPA, October 29, 2025). The full list is published on the City Journal College Rankings site.

Selected results, compared with U.S. News

The new list looks very different from the familiar U.S. News ranking. Public flagships in Florida and Texas did especially well, while several highly ranked universities placed much lower:

University City Journal rank (2025) U.S. News national rank (2026 edition)
University of Florida 1 30
University of Texas at Austin 2 30
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill 3 26
Texas A&M University 4 51
Georgia Institute of Technology 6 32
Florida State University 7 51
University of Virginia 16 26
University of Michigan 31 20
University of California, Davis 39 32
University of California, Los Angeles 40 17
University of California, San Diego 72 29

Sources: City Journal ranks as reported by UF News and OCPA; U.S. News ranks from Forward Pathway’s U.S. college rankings. The press release also singled out Harvard as underperforming on free expression, curricular rigor and ideological balance.

UF also ranked second for return on investment, and Florida State third. UF’s leaders, Board of Trustees Chair Mori Hosseini and Interim President Donald W. Landry, told the campus in an email that “this recognition for UF is something we should all be proud of” (UF News).

How to read a ranking like this

Every ranking reflects the priorities of whoever builds it. U.S. News weights graduation and retention rates, graduate outcomes, faculty and financial resources and peer reputation; Times Higher Education and QS focus on research and international reputation; the City Journal list deliberately rewards curricular breadth, free speech and viewpoint diversity, values associated with the Manhattan Institute, a conservative think tank. Critics have argued that its star scale layered on a 0–100 score adds emphasis without much analytical clarity (RealClearEducation, December 2025).

That does not make the list useless. If you care about a structured core curriculum, open debate in class or a low cost relative to graduates’ earnings, its sub-scores can point you to schools worth a closer look. But it says little about research strength, specific majors or graduate programs, which matter most to many international students.

Latest

We have not found a newer edition of the City Journal rankings. In the 2027 U.S. News Best Colleges rankings, UF and UT Austin both placed No. 34 among national universities, UNC-Chapel Hill No. 27 and Georgia Tech No. 29 (Forward Pathway rankings). UF had been ranked No. 7 among public universities in the 2026 U.S. News edition (Florida Phoenix, September 23, 2025).

Tips for international students

  • Use several rankings, not one. Check where a school stands in U.S. News, QS and THE as well as niche lists, and look at the ranking of your intended major: Forward Pathway’s program rankings and world rankings put them side by side.
  • Look at the underlying data. Graduation rates, international student numbers, tuition for out-of-state students and post-graduation earnings are more useful than an overall number. Each school’s page on Forward Pathway, such as the University of Florida page, shows these figures from IPEDS.
  • Remember the cost difference. Return-on-investment scores are usually based on in-state costs. International students pay out-of-state tuition at public universities, so their payback period will be longer.

References

#University of Florida#University Rankings#academic freedom

Comparing colleges?

Put up to six colleges side by side: rankings, admission rates, costs and graduation rates.

Compare colleges