Skip to content
College News

Broker Fees in New York City and Massachusetts: What Renters Pay Now

Published Updated 5 min read

New York City and Massachusetts, home to many of the universities international students choose, are two of the most expensive rental markets in the United States. For years, renters there often paid a broker fee of about one month’s rent — or, in New York, 12% to 15% of a year’s rent — even when the broker worked for the landlord. Together with first month’s rent, last month’s rent and a security deposit, moving in could cost about three months’ rent upfront (Northeastern Global News, July 2025). In 2025, both places changed the rules. This guide explains what renters can and cannot be charged now, and what students renting off campus should watch for.

New rental rules ease tenant financial burden, but affordability challenges persist

New York City: the FARE Act

The City’s Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses (FARE) Act took effect on June 11, 2025, after a federal judge refused to block it (The Real Deal, June 2025). Its main rules:

  • Whoever hires the broker pays. If a broker lists an apartment for the landlord, the landlord pays that broker, not the tenant.
  • No forced brokers. A landlord or agent may not make renting a unit conditional on the tenant hiring an agent.
  • Fees must be disclosed. Any fee a tenant must pay has to be clearly disclosed in the listing.
  • Tenants can still hire their own broker to search for them, and in that case they pay that broker.

The real estate industry challenged the law in court; in July 2026 a federal appeals court rejected the main challenge from the Real Estate Board of New York (The Real Deal, July 2026).

Enforcement. The city’s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) enforces the law. By mid-October 2026 it had issued 91 summonses alleging 130 violations, 55 violations had resulted in $60,000 in penalties, and more than $24,000 in fees had been returned to tenants. DCWP had received more than 2,500 complaints and questions. Renters have reported brokers advertising “off-market” units that require a fee, or relabeling fees as “management,” “finder’s” or similar charges; DCWP treats requiring a tenant to hire an agent for a specific unit as a violation (Brownstoner / THE CITY, October 2026).

Other New York State rules also limit move-in costs: security deposits are capped at one month’s rent, and before a lease is signed a landlord may charge at most $20 for a credit and background check — and only if it gives the applicant a copy (applicants can avoid the fee by providing their own check from the past 30 days) (New York Attorney General: Residential Tenants’ Rights Guide).

Massachusetts: tenant-paid broker fees banned from August 1, 2025

A Massachusetts law that took effect on August 1, 2025 follows the same principle: broker fees for rentals must be paid by the person who hired the broker. A landlord cannot hire a broker and pass the cost to the tenant through a broker fee or any similarly named fee. A tenant can still hire a broker to represent them, and then the tenant pays. The law is not retroactive for leases signed earlier (Mass.gov: FAQ on residential rental broker’s fees; GBH News, August 2025). Attorney General Andrea Campbell’s office has said a broker may charge a tenant only if the broker is working for the tenant and not for the landlord (Massachusetts AG advisory).

Massachusetts already strictly limits what landlords may collect before move-in: the first month’s rent, last month’s rent, a security deposit of no more than one month’s rent, and the cost of a new lock (M.G.L. c. 186, § 15B). Renters charged illegal fees can file a complaint with the Attorney General’s office, and under the state consumer protection law they may be able to recover up to three times the amount plus attorney’s fees.

Will rents go up instead?

Economists expected some of the cost to move into rent. Northeastern economist John Kwoka noted that in tight markets landlords can pass costs to tenants, and that “the problem begins and ends with the housing supply.” Northeastern researcher Patrice Williams called the change a step in the right direction but said more policies are needed to keep housing affordable (Northeastern Global News). Even without a broker fee, students should budget for high monthly rents in both markets and compare the total cost over the lease, not just the upfront payment.

Tips for students renting off campus in New York and Massachusetts

  1. Start with university housing services. Many universities have off-campus housing offices, listing sites and lease review help. Some graduate students find university-affiliated apartments cheaper than the open market.
  2. Ask who the broker works for before you pay anything. If the broker represents the landlord, you should not pay a broker fee.
  3. Get every fee in writing and compare it with the listing. Be careful with new fee names such as “administrative,” “management” or “finder’s” fees.
  4. Know the caps: in New York, a security deposit of one month and no more than $20 for a credit and background check; in Massachusetts, only first month, last month, a security deposit up to one month, and a lock fee.
  5. Plan for credit history. New international students usually have no U.S. credit score or U.S. income. Landlords may ask for a guarantor, sometimes one who lives in the U.S. and earns a multiple of the rent. Ask early what the landlord accepts, such as proof of funds, a university guarantor program if one exists, or a third-party guarantor service, and read the fees.
  6. Avoid scams. Do not wire money for a unit you have not seen or verified, and be careful with listings far below market price or landlords who say they are abroad.
  7. Read the lease for its length, renewal terms, subletting rules, and who pays for utilities and repairs. Leases usually run 12 months, which may not match the academic year.
  8. Report violations. In New York City, contact DCWP; in Massachusetts, contact the Attorney General’s consumer hotline.

References

#student housing

Comparing colleges?

Put up to six colleges side by side: rankings, admission rates, costs and graduation rates.

Compare colleges